We Tried 25 Buffalo Wild Wings Flavors—and These Are Our Favorites

If there is one thing that makes Buffalo Wild Wings a big hit, it is their diverse selection of sauces and spice rubs.

best buffalo wild wings flavors

Hadn’t it been for the sheer variety and exciting sauce flavors, Buffalo Wild Wings would perhaps be just another fried snack. But their range of sauces and rubs ensures that there is an option for everyone, whether you prefer sticky sweet goodness or a punch of spice.

Now, with the bottled versions of these sauces available online, you can enjoy these sauces with more than just buffalo wings.

There are currently 25 different flavors at Buffalo Wild Wings, with more added every year. The chain rotates flavors among its restaurant locations throughout the year, but there are some that are permanent menu items.

  1. Asian Zing Sauce
  2. Blazin Carolina Reaper
  3. Buffalo Seasoning
  4. Caribbean Jerk Sauce
  5. Chipotle BBQ Seasoning
  6. Desert Heat Seasoning
  7. Honey BBQ Sauce
  8. Hot Sauce
  9. Jammin Jalapeno Sauce
  10. Lemon Pepper Seasoning
  11. Lemon Pepper Sauce
  12. Mango Habanero
  13. Medium Sauce
  14. Mild Sauce
  15. Nashville Hot
  16. Orange Chicken Sauce
  17. Parmesan Garlic Sauce
  18. Teriyaki Sauce
  19. Thai Curry Wing Sauce
  20. Salt and Vinegar Seasoning
  21. Signature Bloody Mary
  22. Southwestern Ranch
  23. Spicy Garlic Sauce
  24. Sweet BBQ Sauce
  25. Wild Sauce

We’ve been to every Buffalo Wild Wings in Manhattan and Brooklyn to try every single flavor of wings they have. Spoiler: They’re all delicious, but some are more delicious than others. After eating way too many wings over the last few weeks, we’ve narrowed it down to the best of the best.

Here are our 16 favorite flavors in order, from worst to best:

16. Orange Chicken

The orange chicken wing was my least favorite out of 16. The flavor is average in my opinion.

I was expecting a lot more than what I got. I was hoping for a sauce that tasted like its name. It is a little sweet, but still has a subtle spice to it. I will most likely pass over this flavor again in the future.

It’s not great, but it’s not bad either.

15. Honey BBQ

The best things about the Honey BBQ sauce are its deep color and thickness. The luscious dark brown and gooey sauce adds a glossy, rich look to anything it coats. The sauce drips off and pools into puddles, leaving enough for dipping.

However, the flavor does not hold up to its gourmet look. It is sweet with a touch of spice. The smokiness is subtle. Hence, it barely qualifies as a barbecue sauce. This sauce is also not too great as a dip.

The Honey BBQ Wild wings sauce holds greater appeal for youngsters who enjoy sticky sweet flavors than grown-ups.

14. Thai Curry

The nutty aroma of coconut milk, softly simmering spices, and creamy flavors inspire Thai Curry buffalo wild wings sauce. However, it does not subscribe to the exact recipe of traditional Thai curries.

You can taste the coconut, sweet chilies, and lemongrass in the sauce. However, it is drowned by equally strong flavors of various other spices. Although the sauce has heat, it is not overpowering. The Thai curry sauce is thick but not too sticky. It is saltier than most Buffalo Wild Wing sauces and has a rich texture from the chunky ingredients in it.

13. Lemon Pepper Sauce

I found the Buffalo Wild Wings Lemon Pepper Sauce to be a great balance of buttery lemon and pepper. The sauce was thick enough that it stuck to the wings nicely and I liked that it wasn’t too overpowering.

The only area where the sauce could use some improvement is more pepper. I really wish there had been more pepper in it because I love spicy food but if you don’t like your wings too spicy then this would be the perfect sauce for you.

I enjoy the sauce more than the dry rub on the wings. When I go to Buffalo Wild Wings, I have never received too much sauce. They always give you enough.

12. Chipotle BBQ Seasoning

I buy this seasoning from Amazon and it can be a little pricey but I think it’s worth every penny.

My husband and I have used it on chicken wings, burgers, and even tofu. We are both very happy with the flavor of this product. It’s spicy but not too spicy. Great smokey flavor with a BBQ touch. We are very happy with the results we get from this product.

This is my go-to seasoning when I’m making chicken wings at home. It’s not only great for chicken, but you can use it on your ribs or even burgers!

11. Mild Sauce

Mild is one of our favorite classic hot sauces at Buffalo Wild Wings.

It’s not concentrated enough to satisfy the needs of a hardcore wing addict, but then again, that’s not what it’s made for. For those who enjoy milder flavors and more delicate wings, this is the perfect sauce to add just enough spice to keep your tongue occupied while leaving your stomach unscathed.

If you’re with someone who doesn’t like spicy food – or if you’re dining with kids – order some mild wings.

10. Nashville Hot

Nashville Hot sauce is an addictive, exciting sauce. It is hot, spicy, and bursting with flavor. The heat is perfectly balanced with just a hint of sweetness.

This sauce has a signature smokiness. Whether you soak meat or vegetables in this sauce or use it as a dip, it will be irresistibly delicious.

Although the sauce was introduced with a fried chicken sandwich, you can use it for much more. Pair it with creamy pasta or vegetables. Or even balance the fiery heat of the Nashville hot sauce with decadent chocolate.

9. Blazin Carolina Reaper

When I first heard about the Blazin Carolina Reaper, I was extremely excited to try it. This is the hottest pepper in the world, and I was anxious to see what all the hype was about.

This sauce is very spicy, so beware. I would say that it is one of the hottest BBQ sauces I have ever had, definitely hotter than many other sauces that are on the market today. Although this sauce is not quite as hot as a pure specimen of the Carolina Reaper, it still made my mouth feel warm and tingly.

8. Jammin Jalapeno

Jammin jalapeno was a limited-edition flavor by the brand. However, it was added to the permanent menu of Buffalo Wild Wings by popular demand. If a sauce managed to build a whole community of raving fans, isn’t it evident that it has something exotic to offer?

In terms of taste, Jammin Jalapeno is one of the spiciest sauces on the menu. It is a sauce that is ideally suited for those who can tolerate very hot and spicy flavors. Lemon is the flavor in the spotlight. Although there should be flavors of tequila within the sauce, it is barely discernible. Jammin Jalapeno has excellent texture as it neatly coats an ingredient without slipping off.

7. Mango Habanero

Mango Habanero is an exotic flavor combination. What begins as a sweet and tangy bite quickly gives way to the intense heat of the habanero pepper. It is certainly not a flavor for the faint-hearted. But if you are fond of fiery hot sauces, you will love Mango Habanero.

The texture of the sauce is divinely appealing. It is sticky, sweet, and thick. This sauce will liven up any bland dish and add truckloads of flavor to a meal. It is one of those sauces that will be the highlight of the entire meal and keep you digging in, even if you are full.

6. Desert Heat Seasoning

I’ve been a fan of this seasoning for years now. The flavor is bold and delicious, the heat is on point, and the fact that it’s dry rub is my favorite part. The flavor is so unique and strong, but it doesn’t overpower your wings by being too salty or too spicy.

This seasoning gives my wings and fries exactly what they need to be perfect. If you prefer to eat your wings dry-rubbed, this is a good option. Instead of using a messy sauce, this spice rub gets the job done and leaves you with easier cleanup.

5. Caribbean Jerk

The complex flavor of an exciting spice blend makes the Caribbean Jerk sauce a winner. And if you find yourself drawn to the spice mix, the heat only makes it better. Bite into your buffalo wings drenched in this sauce, and your tastebuds will be dancing in all directions. Pungent, sweet, peppery, tangy; it is a harmonious marriage of all these flavors and more.

Wild Wings Caribbean jerk slightly deviates from the flavors of authentic jerk chicken. It is not as fiery. Nonetheless, this sauce hits all the right spots. It goes well with all types of meat. Pair it with a lemony drink or dessert to enhance its rich flavors.

4. Wild Sauce

What does “wild” bring to your mind—heat, spice, complex flavors, gamey goodness? This sauce delivers all these factors. It is fiery hot, and the flavors are intriguing.  It is tart, sweet, hot, and complex.

As their hottest buffalo sauce, the heat is expected. However, it can turn out to be quite overpowering, to the extent that it masks the other flavors. The smokey aspect of the sauce also adds to the excitement. So, if you are after intense heat, go for the wild sauce. But if you are looking for a mix of well-balanced flavors, keep exploring.

3. Spicy Garlic

I love this sauce! If you are a Buffalo wild wings fan you know that their spicy garlic sauce is one of their best. It has a great garlic flavor and just enough spice to make it interesting, but not too much to make you lick your lips till they bleed.

I loved this sauce so much that I decided to buy some online to enjoy at home. I use it on my chicken wings, ribs, burgers, and just about everything else. The spicy garlic flavor is incredible and it goes great with just about anything you want to put it on.

The Spicy Garlic sauce is a spicy option that scores points for flavor, but the Parmesan Garlic is tastier.

2. Asian Zing

This Buffalo Wild Wings flavor is true to its name. It is full of signature Asian flavors and is sweet, spicy, zingy, and sticky. The sauce brings together the deep and rich color of soy with the heat of chilies and ginger. There is a citrusy zing that leaves a strong aftertaste.

Asian Zing can add character to any bland dish. Use it to transform any boring meal of meat, potatoes, or vegetables into an Asian delicacy. It will also work well as a side for chips or in a dressing for salads.

1. Parmesan Garlic

If you like creamy, white sauces more than spice-laden, gooey, red, and brown sauces try the Parmesan Garlic Buffalo Wild Wing sauce. It is creamy, buttery, and luscious. The flavors of parmesan and garlic mix perfectly to form a delightfully indulgent sauce.

Although parmesan garlic is creamy, it is not too thick. It spreads smoothly. It will not hurt your taste buds and is guaranteed to be a favorite with kids. Keep parmesan garlic sauce handy for anytime you want to cool your tongue after burning it with spicy food. It will turn down the heat and satiate your appetite.

To wrap it up…

Buffalo sauces taste good on almost anything, not just wild wings. So, isn’t it great that it is available in bottles at their stores and online?

With the details about each of their top flavors, you should be able to identify your favorites. So, what are you waiting for? Stock up on the sauces you like most and indulge in the gourmet goodness of the best buffalo wild wings sauces whenever you crave it.

Add Comment