7 Best Store-Bought Honey Mustard Brands: My Top Picks!

Mustard has found its place in several cuisines around the world, as a condiment. The tastes of sandwiches, hot dogs, and hamburgers are elevated with the addition of mustard sauce on them. There is a wide variety of mustards and their tastes vary from sweet to spicy depending on the ingredients used.

best honey mustard

Honey mustard is one such variety and it has been widely accepted by young and old alike. Blending mustard and honey at the fine ratio of 1:1 and mixing it with vinegar or any other preferred flavor oil gives you the sweet, tangy, tasty Honey Mustard. As a sandwich spread, as a dip for nuggets and fries, or as salad dressing, Honey Mustard has found its place on our food tables. Besides the vinegar and oil, it can also be mixed with herbs or other spices. Dijon mustard is the most commonly chosen base for Honey Mustard.

From the long list of Honey Mustard brands available in the market, each person’s choice would be depending on their preference of taste and ingredients. The balance of sweet, tart and tangy flavors are what makes Honey Mustard brands distinct from each other. Different types of mustard, honey, and seasonings or herbs used in the sauce also bring distinct changes between each brand.

Let us take a look at 7 most prominent Honey Mustard brands:

7. Honeycup Uniquely Sharp Mustard

honeycup uniquely sharp mustardbuy now

A brand that grew from a local home recipe to a long-running company. Honeycup describes their product to be “Divinely spicy, uniquely sharp, decadently delicious”. It is Kosher and has a brown color. The major ingredients in Honeycup are brown sugar, mustard flour, honey, cider vinegar, spices, Canola oil, and salt. Honeycup has a molasses-like sweetness with a pinch of spiciness. It is best used as pretzel stick dip, salad dressing, glazing for meat, etc.

5g of Honeycup Uniquely Sharp Mustard contains:

  • Calories: 20
  • Sugars: 2g
  • Protein: 0g
  • Total Fat: 1.5g

The brand is said to contain no artificial flavors, colorings, or added high fructose. Honeycup has brought two types of honey mustard sauce to the market:

Original Mustard: smooth texture, golden brown color.

Stone Ground Mustard: coarse, rustic texture as the mustard is stone ground. This variety is found to be accepted among all types of consumers.

6. Beaver Brand Sweet Honey Mustard

beaver brand sweet honey mustardbuy now

Another local run business that was started to overcome the Great Depression grew into one of the largest manufacturers of condiments in the United States. With mustard seeds, soybean oil, garlic, turmeric, and other spices, Beaver brand Honey mustard is slightly on the spicy side of honey mustard. This Kosher and Gluten-free brand is widely accepted among a large number of customers. The sauce comes in squeezable bottles, which gives an added comfort of use. The brand markets its Honey Mustard with the tag of an “all-around” condiment; For pretzels, salads, nuggets, burgers, and more.

5g of Beaver Honey Mustard contains:

  • Calories: 15
  • Sugars: 2g
  • Protein: 0g
  • Total Fat: 0g

The low content of fat makes Beaver Honey Mustard a preferred choice for those with dietary restrictions. Its ingredients are also favorable to ensure easy digestion.

5. Boar’s Head All Natural Honey Mustard

boar's head all natural honey mustardbuy now

Founded in 1905, Boar’s Head was based on a motto to craft better quality and higher standard food products. This is also a family-owned brand and they have a wide range of different products from ham and other meat and cheese to different types of condiments like dips and spreads.

Boar’s Head Honey Mustard is made using all-natural honey and specially hand-selected mustard seeds. The mustard seeds are ground right when they are fresh and finely blended with the honey. The other contents include several spices, salt, vinegar, and molasses. But the one ingredient that stands out is the grated horseradish. This lends a kick of spice to the honey mustard sauce. The tang from horseradish is what makes Boar’s Head different from the other brands.

The brand ensures zero MSG and no added Caramel color. This honey mustard is Gluten-free and goes great with turkey-cheese sandwiches or as a salad dressing.

5g of Boar’s Head Honey Mustard contains:

  • Calories: 10
  • Sugars: 1g
  • Protein: 0g
  • Total Fat: 0g

The savory aroma of Boar’s head is also worth mentioning. It is sure to be appetising for everyone, young and old.

4. French’s Honey Mustard

french’s honey mustardbuy now

French’s is a brand that is famous for its “ALL AMERICAN TASTE” tag. They started off with the classic Yellow mustard and has now grown to a brand with a wide range of condiments, sauces, snacks, etc. French’s honey mustard is one that goes on the sweet side of Honey mustard sauces. The texture of French’s is what makes it different from the other prominent brands in the market.

French’s use grade 1 mustard seeds, honey, spices, garlic powder, and vinegar as their major ingredients. This does not contain any artificial coloring, but they use Carrot Oleoresin as the coloring agent. This Kosher, Gluten free honey mustard is also free from high fructose corn syrup. French’s honey mustard is mostly preferred as a dipping sauce but goes good as a spread for your sandwiches too.

5g of French’s Honey Mustard contains:

  • Calories: 10
  • Sugars: <1g
  • Protein: 0g
  • Total Fat: 0g

The addition of French’s honey mustard in Vinaigrettes and marinades can give their taste a very pleasing twist.

3. Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce

sweet baby ray's honey mustard dipping saucebuy now

A brand established in 1985, Sweet Baby Ray’s started off with their award-winning Barbecue sauce. Their Honey Mustard is known for its use as a condiment on grilled sweet corn and pork tenderloin. Dijon mustard, Honey, egg yolk, soybean oil, spices, and salt are among the major ingredients in Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey Mustard. One important fact about the ingredients in Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey Mustard is that they have less than 2% of salt, spices, etc.

30g of Sweet Baby Ray’s Honey Mustard contains:

  • Calories: 130
  • Sugars: 6g
  • Protein: 0g
  • Total Fat: 11g

This product has a slightly sweet taste that does not overpower the dish you are siding it with. Chicken nuggets and such that are dipped in Sweet Baby Ray’s honey mustard would taste a lot better with the light sweetness with the retained chicken flavor.

2. Heinz Honey Mustard

heinz honey mustardbuy now

Since 1869 Heinz has stayed one of the best condiments brands across the world. Heinz Honey Mustard is made with 100% pure natural honey and the classic stone-ground mustard seeds. The other major ingredients in Heinz Honey Mustard are distilled white vinegar, cane sugar, spices, turmeric, molasses, etc. The inverted squeezable bottle packing makes it convenient and easy to use. It is Kosher certified and goes excellent as a dip for chicken and spread on hot dogs, sandwiches, and burgers.

Heinz Honey Mustard is of premium quality but available at the most affordable prices than the other honey mustard sauces available in the market. Though it has a rich taste, the sweetness goes in line with the tartness of the spices and hence not overpowering the taste of the main dish.

6g of Heinz Honey Mustard contains:

  • Calories: 10
  • Sugars: 1g
  • Protein: 0g
  • Total Fat: 0g

1. Ken’s Steak House Squeezable Honey Mustard

ken's steak house squeezable honey mustardbuy now

Ken’s SteakHouse is a family-run brand that has its own restaurant in Massachusetts. They are known for the different types of salad dressings.

The honey mustard from Ken’s steakhouse is made from pure honey and it has a rich creamy flavor. The major ingredients include distilled vinegar, vegetable oil, egg yolk, and 2% less spices, paprika, salt, etc. It has added colors and high fructose corn syrup. Ken’s Steakhouse honey mustard is Kosher and Gluten-free.

It goes excellent as dressing, topping or dip.The sauce comes in easy to use squeezable inverted bottles.

30g of Ken’s Steakhouse Honey Mustard contains:

  • Calories: 130
  • Sugars: 6g
  • Protein: 0g
  • Total fat: 11g

Tips while using honey mustard:

  • Always shake the bottle well before using.
  • Once opened, keep it refrigerated for retaining the freshness and quality.
  • Make sure you check the ingredients and best-buy date when purchasing.

Honey mustard is a condiment that has the fine balance of sweetness, tartness, and spiciness to go with your favorite snacks, sandwiches, burgers, chips, etc. But always keep an eye on the calorie intake with each serving and thereby ensure you are not overconsuming.

Grab your pick of honey mustard and dip, top and spread as you like!

Add Comment